Cashless Operations: Part II

In a previous article I discussed the idea of requiring all government transactions to be conducted by check or bank deposit, as a "corruption-proofing" measure. Well, I have a little more to say on the subject.

Government is currently involved in an all out drive to raise new revenue through new taxes. At first glance that doesn't seem like a bad idea. But additional revenue simply won't make any difference in solving this country's problems, and I'll tell you why. The National Treasury "bucket" is full of holes. But these are no ordinary holes. The amount of money that leaks out through these holes, meaning the amount stolen through graft and corruption, is not a fixed number like other expenses. The amount stolen is actually always a percentage of whatever is available. This means that no matter how much more we collect, more will be stolen. And the leakage is not small. The Philippine Center for Investigative Journalism is reporting today that up to 70% of local health funds are stolen by corrupt government officials. Not 5% or even 20% like the Mafia might take, but 70%! It's a wonder there is any money left after everyone gets their cut.

This tells us that there is very little, if any, control over the handling of government money. Sure, we have a whole book full of rules and regulations, but they are simply not enforced. The Finance secretary just reported that government will be filing new cases against corrupt BIR and Customs officials each week. But filing cases depends on catching those people. We'll certainly catch some, and it's important to prosecute them quickly, but those will really only be a drop in the bucket. The system is just too well entrenched, and too many people are involved, to be stopped by a few arrests. What we really have to do is gain physical control over the money itself. We may not be able to force people to be honest, but it is possible to make it very hard for them to hide the money they steal.

The way to do that, as I said before, is simply to STOP USING CASH! One of the suppliers of medicines to a local government, quoted in the PCIJ report, said it very clearly. "Mayors prefer cash, since checks leave a trail." Well, there you go! The bad guys avoid checks like a thief avoids the light. So why don't we shine a little light on the money trail and see where it leads?

Prohibiting the use of cash is one of the easiest moves government can make, and the very minor administrative costs would immediately be offset by the incredible gains in financial control. I suspect that the Department of Finance can probably implement such a policy without need for any new laws. Just advise all government units, at all levels, that from now on, funds will only be disbursed through bank transfers to each unit's official bank account. And then advise each of those units that the only way funds may be disbursed is by check. In fact, any government unit or office can already implement such a procedure within its own jurisdiction. The Armed Forces could do it, a city government could do it...we don't have to wait to be told.

This procedure certainly won't stop corruption, but it will definitely make it harder to get away with it. As a matter of fact, if we actually enforce it, we might even be able to reverse the numbers on corruption pretty quickly. How about 30% stolen and 70% actually used to buy medicines and health care? Not the end of the fight, but a definite improvement. And I believe it's very, very possible.